J.T Tuimoloau, EDGE, Ohio State (Senior)

The 2025 NFL Draft is fast approaching, and despite an initial impression that this year's class might lack talent, The Trick Play team has once again delved into the tapes to bring you scouting reports on the players who will soon wear the jerseys of your favorite franchises.

From Quarterback to Safety, including the trenches where Offensive Linemen and Defensive Linemen engage in a relentless battle, Rayane and Valentin will walk you through the new faces of this 2025 draft class while everyone is excited about the coming NFL Draft


Strengths
:

  • Dominant and powerful
  • Size
  • Good punch
  • Takeoff
  • Pass rush moves
  • Willing and disciplined
  • Leverage
  • Gap control

 

Weaknesses :

  • Efforts in order to stay squared
  • Attacks too much on the shoulder
  • Too late to get in position
  • Average pass rush plan
  • Bend
  • Good everywhere but not excellent anywhere
  • Potential
  • Complexes developpement

TTProfil

Fresh off a national championship title with the Buckeyes, J.T. Tuimoloau was one of the key contributors to Ohio State’s strong defensive season. But what might make you want to draft him—or, on the contrary, leave him off your list of targets next April? That’s exactly what we’re going to dive into.
 
J.T is, above all, a dominant player. He’s powerful, and that clearly shows in his playing style, which—as you might have guessed—leans heavily toward the power rusher archetype. And to be fair, he definitely has the frame for it. While you should always take ESPN’s listed numbers with a grain of salt until official measurements are confirmed, watching the tape suggests that his currently listed size online doesn’t seem far off the mark.
At 6'5" and 269 lbs (officially listed at 6'4" – 265 lbs post-Combine), Tuimoloau is a sturdy player who doesn’t hesitate to use his weight to put pressure on the opposing offensive line.
 
He notably possesses a solid punch that feels both heavy and powerful, and he uses it effectively to create space in run situations or to open a lane for a pass-rush move. This is a strong asset, especially since he doesn’t hesitate to lean into his power in any situation. As a result, it’s not uncommon to see J.T. dominate when using his bull-rush, as he’s able to generate impressive upper body strength.
 
However, his upper body strength isn’t the only physical trait worth noting—he’s also capable of generating just as much power from his lower body. This allows him, once again, to be dominant, particularly when he needs to hold his gap responsibilities in run situations.
What's more, this good lower-body strength can also be felt on his Takeoff, as he's rather explosive on his exit from Stance.
 
Now that we’ve covered Tuimoloau’s physical traits, let’s move on to his technique—an area where he also holds his own. While we’ve already briefly mentioned his Bull-rush, which remains one of his favorite weapons, J.T. actually has a more complete arsenal of pass rush moves than one might expect from someone labeled as a Power Rusher archetype.
Of course, we’re still a long way off from the level of someone like Laiatu Latu (Colts), who was exceptional in this regard, but it's still solid for a player of his archetype. On the power rush side, we find the usuals—Bull-rush, Push-pull, Rip move, and a Club move that he occasionally pulls out when needed. J.T. also seems to have been trying to develop a Long Arm move over the past two seasons, but it’s still too tentative in my opinion—which is a shame, given the power he displays when trying to create separation with his punch. This will definitely need further work at the pro level, as it could become a valuable weapon in the future. What’s especially interesting, beyond those power moves, are the flashes he's shown over the past two years in speed rush techniques. In particular, he tends to rely on a quick and well-executed Swim move, some nice activity and upper-body flexibility when swiping hands away, and a Spin move that he mostly uses as a counter. While that Spin move isn’t elite, it at least adds another tool to his toolbox.
It's encouraging, and a good basis for the coaching staff to work on.
 
Overall, Tuimoloau is a willing and disciplined player, and this is especially evident in run situations. J.T. consistently gives maximum effort, unlike some other edge rushers I’ve observed over the years who thrive when it comes to hunting down the quarterback but tend to ease off when it’s time to get their hands dirty in the trenches.
That's a trait I really appreciate in him, especially since, as I mentioned, he remains disciplined in his effort. Give him the responsibility to hold the contain and he'll get it done. Ask him to sacrifice himself by taking on two blockers to free up a blitz and he'll do it. All good things on that front.
 
Another point that may be more noticeable when he's facing a running play than during his pass rush reps is that J.T. plays with a low pad level. He benefits from excellent leverage, which helps him a lot against offensive tackles with increasingly monstrous measurements. Thanks to this leverage, as well as his physical and technical skills, it’s not surprising to see Tuimoloau dominate in run-stopping situations. He's especially strong when it comes to gap control and is often able to bounce the play outside, even if he doesn't end up securing the tackle himself, allowing his teammates to capitalize on the good play made by J.T.
 
With his strengths out of the way, it's time to turn to the little flaws present in every young player coming out of university.
One area of concern is J.T.'s tendency to turn his shoulders a bit too quickly, whether in run or pass situations. To become more effective in the NFL, he'll need to put in more effort to stay square (meaning keeping his shoulders facing the play as much as possible) to avoid giving ball carriers an easy opportunity to bypass him. By maintaining better body alignment, he can prevent opponents from getting around him too easily.
 
Another potential issue for Tuimoloau once he reaches the NFL is his tendency to attack the play with his shoulder when penetrating inside the line. This is noticeable both in pass rush situations, such as when he's executing a stunt, and sometimes in run defense, where he seems to believe that by driving his shoulder into the gap, it will be effectively sealed off. This approach could become problematic in the NFL, as more refined offensive linemen may exploit this tendency and create openings.
So far, J.T has had varying degrees of success with this decision-making, and I emphasize the "less" because, from what I've seen, it hasn't always been a reliable approach. The level of competition in the NFL is much higher, and by choosing to attack with his shoulder in this way, he risks getting trapped in blocks, effectively taking himself out of the play entirely. This is something he'll need to adjust and refine in order to succeed at the next level.
It’s especially disappointing to see this because of the strong punch he has, which could allow him to achieve the same result—penetrating the line—while maintaining good separation from blockers. This would give him a better chance of making the play if the opportunity arises, and it’s a skill he could use to his advantage if he refines his technique.
 
Let's focus on a point that could impact all aspects of his game: J.T. sometimes takes too long to get set before the play starts. When this happens, he can find himself completely behind, leading to him losing his rep. This delay can affect his ability to be effective on both passing and running plays, making him more vulnerable to being outpaced or overpowered by his opponents.
This isn't a point that will be difficult to correct, but if he wants to succeed in the pros and establish himself over the long term, lapses in concentration like this cannot happen—especially not repeatedly. Unfortunately, this is something that appears too often in the tapes, and it’s a habit that could hinder his development at the next level.
 
Now that we've discussed some of the small flaws that could affect all types of plays (both pass and run), let's focus a bit more on J.T.'s pass rush and specifically two points.
The first point is a somewhat underdeveloped pass rush plan. Let me explain: a player's pass rush plan becomes crucial once they reach the NFL due to the higher level of competition faced by edge rushers coming straight out of college.
Think of it like a level-up in a video game. Until now, you've been breezing through on easy and medium difficulty, but now you're jumping to hard mode. It’s no longer about charging straight in; it's about having a real strategy. That’s what a pass rush plan represents.
For most of these young players, they've been dominating since high school by relying on their strengths—whether physical, technical, or tactical. They've used and abused these advantages, but the level drastically changes once they reach the NFL. Now, it’s about strategy. Luring the O-line with certain moves for X number of plays, and then pulling out a different move at the right moment to completely beat the same blocker, who expects anything but that. This is the key to having a solid pass rush plan. As of now, Tuimoloau relies on what he knows and plays largely on instinct. While this can still work against certain physical or technical monsters, it won’t be enough for J.T. at the pro level. I find it hard to see him dominate consistently in his pass rush if he continues like this. That’s why it will be crucial for him to develop a true pass rush plan if he wants to become a complete and dominant player in the future.
 
Let’s close this long parenthesis on the pass rush plan to bring up another important point for any respectable pass rusher: the bend. As you might have guessed, the reason we’re bringing this up now is because J.T’s bend is rather average.
While Tuimoloau is able to show nice upper-body flexibility when swiping at his opponent's hands before executing a move, that doesn’t always translate when he’s in position to finish a play, even after successfully collapsing the pocket on the opposing QB. I find that disappointing. He could become a much bigger threat with better bend.
 
Finally, the last points of concern I have with Tuimoloau are personal, but in my opinion he unfortunately suffers from the syndrome of players who are good everywhere but excellent nowhere.
Indeed, when watching a game from J.T, he always manages to show up—sometimes on a run stop, sometimes with a big pressure, or by deflecting a pass. However, aside from one monster game during the 2023-2024 season, I don’t see many truly standout performances from him. J.T is a consistent player in terms of overall performance, but rarely consistent in excellence, and ultimately, given what he’s capable of, I find he doesn’t impact opposing offenses nearly as much as he should.
 
With Tuimoloau, we’re looking at a player whose floor certainly seems very high, but whose ceiling remains a mystery to me. Moreover, his areas of development are quite complex upon closer inspection—either they’ll require substantial foundational work, or there’s no guarantee improvement will come, or even if it does, it may not result in a significant leap in J.T’s performance overnight. And that could be problematic when trying to project his role on a roster or determine the value he should be given in the draft.
 
 
 
Ultimately, J.T Tuimoloau is a fairly well-rounded player overall. While he may initially appear to be just a simple Power rusher, he maintains a very intriguing floor that could allow him to stay on the field in any game situation—something that’s bound to catch the interest of many teams. That said, as we’ve seen in his weaknesses, his potential might end up limiting his final draft stock.
If J.T. is very complete, there's nothing to suggest that he could yet make a huge leap forward in his progression and development as a pass rush specialist.
 
As a result, he may never become more than a solid Edge number 2 option in your team at best. In which case, what value should you place on him?
All the more so because while he could fit nicely into a traditional 4-3 front as a Defensive End, additional work would be required to get him ready to play in a 3-4 front as an Outside Linebacker. His age will also play a key role, as some coaches might be more willing to take a chance—especially with a 22-year-old player.
 
For all the reasons I mentioned during this scouting, J.T has slipped into my Tier 3 EDGE despite its undeniable qualities.
Given the level of talent in the trenches this year, I would have no problem letting Tuimoloau slide to the 3rd round before taking interest—but I could also understand if a team that loves this type of profile decided to reach a little.
en_USEnglish